Car Insurance Excess Explained: Compulsory vs Voluntary

A mechanic repairing the rear bodywork of a car in a workshop

This is general information, not advice about which policy is right for you.

A car insurance excess is the amount you pay towards a claim, where an excess applies, before your insurer pays the rest. Most policies have a compulsory excess set by the insurer, and many let you add a voluntary excess on top. The two are added together, so if your total excess is £300 and the repair costs £3,000, you pay £300 and your insurer pays £2,700. How and when you pay it varies between insurers and types of claim. Choosing a higher voluntary excess can lower your premium, but only choose an amount you could afford to pay if you had to claim tomorrow.

Below, we explain how each type of excess works, when you have to pay it, and what to check before you change it.

What is a car insurance excess?

Your excess is your share of the cost of each claim. Ageas describes it as “the amount you’re responsible for paying towards each claim before your insurer contributes.”

In practice, your insurer works out your total excess and takes it off the amount it pays. Ageas gives the example of a £3,000 repair with a £300 total excess: in its example, you pay the £300 to the garage once the work is done, and the insurer pays the remaining £2,700. Other insurers may handle payment differently, so check your policy. If the repair costs the same as your excess or less, your insurer pays nothing, so a small claim may not be worth making at all.

Compulsory vs voluntary excess

Compulsory excess

The compulsory excess is set by your insurer and you cannot change it. Admiral says the figure can vary depending on driving experience, age and the type of car, and Ageas says it can differ depending on the driver, the car and the insurer’s assessment of risk. In practice, young or inexperienced drivers are often asked to pay a higher compulsory excess.

Voluntary excess

The voluntary excess is an extra amount you choose to pay on top of the compulsory excess, when you buy or renew your policy. A higher voluntary excess can lower your premium, but you pay more if you claim. As Admiral puts it: “Lower excess, higher premium or higher excess, lower premium? It’s up to you.”

How the total is worked out

The two amounts are added together to make your total excess. For example:

  • Compulsory excess: £100
  • Voluntary excess: £200
  • Total excess: £300

With a total excess of £300, a claim would need to cost more than £300 before your insurer paid anything towards it. The bigger the total, the more small repairs you end up paying for yourself.

When do you have to pay the excess?

You generally pay your excess whenever you make a claim on your own policy. Ageas says you pay both types of excess after a fire, vandalism or a fault claim that has damaged the car or written it off. If your car is written off, there is no garage bill to pay: Ageas, for example, says it deducts the excess from the settlement value instead.

Windscreen and glass claims

Many policies set a separate excess for windscreen claims, which can differ from the main excess. Check your policy schedule for the exact amounts.

If the accident was not your fault

This is where many drivers are caught out. Admiral says you pay the excess on any claim made on your policy, regardless of who is to blame, but that if it is proved the other driver was at fault and the full cost is recovered from their insurer, you may be able to get the excess back. The Post Office gives the same picture: in most cases you still pay the excess upfront, but you might get it back later if the other driver is found to be at fault and their insurer agrees to pay.

Recovering your excess can take time, and the details depend on your policy, so check your policy wording, including any legal expenses cover, rather than assuming.

How to choose a voluntary excess

  1. Start with what you could pay tomorrow. AXA advises that “you should always choose a realistic amount that you can afford to pay in the case of a claim.” If you could not find the money quickly, the excess is too high.
  2. Add the two figures together. Always look at the total excess, not just the voluntary part. Ageas reminds drivers that they must be able to afford both the voluntary and the compulsory excess.
  3. Weigh the saving against the risk. A lower premium is only worth it if the saving is meaningful compared with the extra you would pay on a claim. For example, if raising your voluntary excess by £200 cuts your premium by £30 a year, you would be accepting another £200 to pay on any qualifying claim in return for that £30 saving. Ageas warns that setting your excess too high could mean covering the full cost of smaller repairs yourself.
  4. Think about small claims. With a high total excess, a minor repair may cost less than your excess, so you would pay the whole bill.
  5. Read the policy schedule. Check the separate figures for windscreen claims and for young or named drivers, as these can differ from the main excess.

Your excess is one of several levers on the price. For others, see our guide on how to cut your car insurance.

What is excess protection insurance?

Excess protection (also called excess insurance) is a separate policy designed to pay you back your excess after a valid claim on your car insurance. It is often offered as an add-on when you buy a policy.

Before you buy it, check:

  • Eligibility: which drivers, cars and types of claim are covered, and whether it works alongside your car insurance policy.
  • Limits: the most it will pay per claim and per year, and how many claims it covers.
  • Exclusions: the claims it will not pay, including what happens if your main insurer rejects the claim.
  • Reimbursement timing: whether you have to pay your excess first, how long it takes to get the money back and what proof you need.
  • Cost: whether the price is worth it compared with the excess you would realistically pay.

Excess and new drivers

New and young drivers are more likely to face a higher compulsory excess, which makes the total excess especially important to check. If you are buying your first policy, our guide to car insurance for new drivers covers the other factors that affect the price, and our guide on choosing a car that costs less to insure explains how the car itself plays a part.

Whatever your situation, check your excess at every renewal, as the amounts can change from year to year and between insurers.

FAQ

Can I change my compulsory excess?

No. The compulsory excess is set by your insurer. You can usually choose or change your voluntary excess instead.

Do I pay the excess if my car is written off?

Usually, yes. The excess is normally taken off the settlement for a written-off car. Check how your policy handles a total loss.

Do I pay the excess if the crash was not my fault?

In most cases you pay it at first. If the other driver is found to be at fault and their insurer pays, you may get your excess back later.

Does a higher voluntary excess always make insurance cheaper?

It often lowers the premium, but the saving varies. It also means you pay more if you claim, so only choose an amount you could afford.

Related: How to Cut Your Car Insurance: 10 Practical Tips for UK Drivers | Car Insurance for New Drivers: A UK Guide | Car Insurance Groups Explained

Sources: Ageas: what is excess in car insurance?; Admiral: what is car insurance excess?; AXA: car insurance excess guide; Post Office: what does excess mean in car insurance?.

Share