This is general information, not advice about which policy is right for you.
Black box insurance, also called telematics insurance, is car insurance that monitors how, when and how far you drive, and uses that information to help set your price. Careful drivers can see cheaper prices or rewards, but it is not guaranteed to save money, and poor driving can push the price up. It tends to suit young and new drivers most, because they usually face the highest premiums.
Here is how it works, what is measured and the rules worth checking before you sign up.
How black box insurance works
A device or app records data about your journeys and sends it to your insurer, which turns it into a driving score that feeds into what you pay. Autotrader describes it as a policy that “records your driving behaviour over time to provide you with a bespoke insurance premium as opposed to a fixed, pre-determined one.”
The different types of device
Which? explains that devices range from GPS trackers that need professional installation to tags you can stick on your windscreen, and Carwow says fitting is often a do-it-yourself job. The main options are:
- A fitted black box: installed by an engineer, usually hidden inside the car.
- A plug-in or self-fit device: sent to you to fit yourself, often in minutes.
- A windscreen tag: a small self-fit unit, usually paired with a smartphone app.
- A smartphone app: uses your phone’s sensors, so you need to carry your phone, charged, on every journey.
What a black box measures
Each insurer has its own scoring system, but policies typically look at:
- Your speed, including whether you keep to the limit
- How hard you brake, accelerate and take corners
- The time of day you drive
- Your mileage and how often you make journeys
- The types of road you use
Some go further. Which? notes that at least one policy also checks whether you manually use your phone while driving.
How your score affects the price
The timing differs between insurers. According to MoneySuperMarket, some black box policies can adjust your price during the policy if your driving score changes, while others use your driving data to help calculate your renewal price.
A poor score can work against you. Confused.com warns that you “could end up paying more at renewal for poor driving,” and Uswitch says risky driving, high mileage or breaking the policy rules can increase costs or invalidate your policy. Under some policies, persistently poor driving scores can lead to cancellation, so check what warnings the insurer gives, whether there is a period to improve, and the cancellation terms.
Is it actually cheaper?
For younger drivers, it often is, but not always. Research by Consumer Intelligence, reported by Which? in November 2025, found that a telematics policy was the cheapest option in 42% of cases overall. For drivers aged 17 to 19, it was cheaper in 82.8% of cases, and the median price difference was £2,172. For drivers aged 35 to 39, telematics was cheaper in only 24.6% of cases. These findings reflect quotes analysed in November 2025, and individual prices will differ.
The rules and catches to check first
- Night-time driving. Uswitch says most modern policies do not impose a strict curfew, but night driving may lower your driving score with some policies. Check the policy wording if you often drive late.
- Mileage limits. Some policies set a mileage limit. Uswitch says going over it usually does not cancel your insurance, but it can make it more expensive, so tell your insurer if your mileage is likely to change.
- Fees. Uswitch notes you may have to pay a fee to move a fitted box to a different car during the policy, and Confused.com says some policies charge to remove the device.
- Other drivers may count. MoneySuperMarket points out that a black box monitors the car, so another person’s driving could be recorded and affect your score. With an app-based policy, it depends on how journeys are recorded and identified, so check how your insurer handles other drivers.
- Read the terms. Which? advises reading the terms and conditions carefully before you sign up, so there are no surprises later.
What happens to your data?
Black box policies collect detailed information about your driving, including where and when you drive. Before you buy, read the insurer’s privacy policy to see what is collected, how it is used, how long it is kept and who it may be shared with.
The data can also help you. Which? says black box insurance can be useful if your car is stolen or if you are involved in a dispute over a claim. How much it helps depends on the device and the policy, for example whether a fitted device can help locate the car.
Who black box insurance suits
It tends to work best for:
- Young and newly qualified drivers facing high quotes (see our guide to car insurance for new drivers)
- Careful drivers who are happy to have their driving monitored
- Low-mileage drivers
- Drivers in other higher-risk groups: Confused.com says those with motoring convictions, and some older drivers, may also find it helps
It may suit you less if you cover high mileage, share the car with a less careful driver or simply do not want your driving monitored. Carwow notes that conventional insurance will often be cheaper, especially if you have a long and clean driving history.
Whichever type of policy you consider, the car itself still matters. Our guide on how to choose a car that costs less to insure as a new driver explains what affects the price before you buy.
Frequently asked questions
Does a black box mean I cannot drive at night?
Not usually. Most modern policies do not impose a strict curfew, but some may score night driving less favourably. Check the policy wording before you buy.
Can black box insurance make my premium go up?
Yes. Poor driving can lead to a higher price at renewal, and breaking the policy rules can increase costs or invalidate the policy.
Can someone else drive my car?
Yes, if they are insured to drive it. Depending on the device and how journeys are identified, their driving may also be recorded and affect your score.
Is black box insurance only for young drivers?
No. It is most common among young and new drivers, but low-mileage drivers and some other groups may also find it worth considering. For many experienced drivers, a standard policy will be cheaper.
Related: How to Cut Your Car Insurance: 10 Practical Tips for UK Drivers · Car Insurance for New Drivers: A UK Guide · Car Insurance Groups 1–50 Explained
Sources: Autotrader: black box insurance for young and new drivers; Which?: how young drivers could save on car insurance; Which?: how black box car insurance works; Which? (November 2025): Consumer Intelligence telematics research; MoneySuperMarket: how does black box insurance work?; Confused.com: telematics explained; Uswitch: types of black box insurance; Carwow: black box insurance explained




